I don’t want to pretend like I actually have any advice for writers. As if I’m some kind of writer. Or wise person. (yeah right).
But I wanted to tell you about something I’ve been thinking about: honesty.
My friend Aaron mentioned it to me a while back. I had shown him a song I was working on, and he said, “It’s good, but I’m not sure you’re being honest.” And what I saw when I looked again, was that my first verse was really contrived. It was trying too hard to tell a story I knew nothing about. The chorus was good. When I wrote a second verse, it was really good. But the song doesn’t work because I never changed the first verse, and it just wasn’t good enough.
They tell you to write what you know. Austin Kleon says to throw that out the window and write what you like, what you want to read. That’s a great idea. I can’t tell you how much I love that idea. But let’s refocus on the first idea- writing what you know. Let’s redefine that. Let’s just say, Write Honest.
You can write whatever you want. Lyrics, poetry, entire trilogies. If you grew up in a small town, you’re not confined to only write about that town, or the people you know or yourself. You should write about Paris. Or Guatemala. Thieves and Princes and unsung Heroes. Or whatever the hell you want. Don’t limit your content- instead, be careful in the way that you write. Be honest.
Be more like these mountains. Mountains are honest.
A lot of this has to do with developing your own personal style. Everyone has a voice and you have to find yours. What does honest writing mean to me? It means that I can read it and believe it. It can be the wildest of fictions but I need your characters- not their setting, clothes, or occupations; the characters– to be real. I want them to act like people act. Or animals, if that’s what they are. Everyone knows people. You know people. What drives us? Hunger, loss, pain, joy, bitterness, jealousy, passion… that ineffable love for another fallible human.
The best things I’ve written have been incredibly personal, and often blunt. I have to dig into what I know, because sometimes I get distracted by what I think, and I have to open up to whatever pain or joy I’m feeling and find out why it’s there and just exactly what it does to me. And then I write a song. Don’t try too hard. Don’t try to be a poet. I sometimes think we are all poets somewhere inside. If you’re honest, the words will come and they’ll fit together and they’ll open up to you, and you’ll see a different side to each letter and syllable and the whole language will sound different, better.
Here’s what you have to do. You have to be honest. You have to write what you know, not with your eyes, but with your soul.